3-2-6 Dime (5-0-6 Dime Bear-Double Eagle Big Dime) - 3 Down Base Defense

Modern offenses operate primarily out of 11 personnel (1 RB, 1 TE, 3 WR) with spread formations, move tight ends, and RPO integration. Traditional base defenses, built for power formations that no longer exist, struggle to match this speed and coverage demands without sacrificing run defense or generating pressure.

The 3-2-6 Big Dime solves this problem by making the "sub package" the base defense. Five-man fronts with three interior linemen who demand double-teams, two hybrid edges who can rush and cover, and six defensive backs (including three hybrid safeties with man coverage ability) create a defense that:

- Matches 11 personnel speed and coverage requirements

- Generates pressure through impossible blocking math (not individual dominance)

- Destroys RPO concepts through pattern-matching and robber principles

- Creates disguised 8-man boxes that punish run attempts

- Adjusts to heavier personnel without structural vulnerability

This isn't situational football. This is the base defense for the game that's actually being played.

Five-Man Line capable of dropping to a three-man:

The three interior linemen are expected to each draw double-team coverage from the average offensive line. This is the baseline expectation, not a bonus, but the default when the scheme is functioning correctly, utilizing the modern player.

1. Anchor Nose Tackle (0-Tech, 2-Gap)

- Alignment: Head-up on the center, controlling both A-gaps

- Role: The foundation of this defense. Must demand consistent double-teams from center plus guard, preventing vertical displacement and keeping blockers occupied. This player needs elite anchor strength, hand placement, and the ability to read flow while holding ground. Without this dominance, the entire scheme collapses because lighter second-level defenders get exposed to combo blocks climbing to the second level.

- Critical Skills: Low pad level, violent hands to shed, ability to submarine or stack-and-shed depending on down/distance.

2. Defensive Tackles (3-Tech & 5-Tech, 2-Gap)

- 3-Tech (B-gap/C-gap responsibility): Lines up on the outside shoulder of the guard but must be able to slide between B-gap (inside) and C-gap (outside the guard, inside the tackle) depending on blocking scheme and run flow. This player penetrates, collapses the pocket on passes, and must be quick enough to shoot gaps or strong enough to two-gap when needed.

- 5-Tech (C-gap/outside responsibility): Lines up on the outside shoulder of the tackle. Responsible for controlling C-gap primarily but must be aware of outside runs bouncing to the D-gap. Sets a firm edge against power/counter, anchors vs. down blocks, and provides interior pocket collapse on pass rush.

- Key Concept: Both DTs must have the versatility to cover B-gap AND C-gap depending on the call, formation, and offensive tendency. This requires exceptional football IQ, lateral agility for their size, and communication with the Jokers/Bucks to ensure gap exchanges are clean.

3. Joker/Buck/Elephant (Hybrid EDGE, C-gap/D-gap/Edge)

- Alignment Flexibility: Can align in 5-tech (outside tackle), 7-tech (inside shoulder of TE), 9-tech (outside shoulder of TE), or wide-9 (outside everything) based on formation and game plan.

- Gap Responsibility: Must cover C-gap, D-gap, and the edge depending on the play call and whether they're playing "contain" or "penetrate" technique. Against 12 or 21 personnel (multiple TEs/FB), they need to be physical enough to set edges vs. kick-out blocks but fast enough to chase down outside zone/stretch plays.

- Versatility Demands: These aren't traditional 4-3 DEs or 3-4 OLBs. They must:

  - Rush the passer with speed/bend (primary function against 11 personnel)

  - Spill runs to the perimeter (forcing the ball outside into your speed)

  - Drop into flat/hook zones to disguise coverage and handle move TEs releasing into routes

  - Execute "Squeeze" technique (attacking inside shoulder of blocker to force runs wider)

  - Play "Read" technique vs. option/RPO (reading the mesh point and reacting)

- Modern Matchup: Against today's move TEs (athletic 6'4", 250 lb receivers), these players must have the speed to carry vertical routes when dropped into coverage and the physicality to re-route at the line of scrimmage.

Secondary Roles: The "Positionless" Second Level

4. Single-High Free Safety 

- The Eraser: A zone player with occasional man ability, last line of defense, responsible for the deep middle third (or half in Cover 2 rotations). Must process route combinations rapidly, have elite range and closing speed, and communicate shell rotations. Think Devin McCourty.

- Modern Responsibility: Against 11 personnel with slot receivers and move TEs running vertical concepts, this player must be able to split the difference between multiple vertical threats and break on the ball at the high point.

5. Man Outside Cornerbacks

- Island Mentality: These players must win 1-on-1 consistently against today's bigger, more physical X and Z receivers. Press-man technique at the line, carry vertical routes, and mirror releases. Their success determines whether the defense can bring extra pressure or play aggressive underneath.

- Run Responsibility: Must set edges vs. perimeter runs (jet sweeps, toss plays), avoid being "stalk blocked" by receivers on outside zone/screens, and tackle in space. Against 11 personnel, they are often the force defender to the boundary.

6. Big Nickel / Robber

- The Hybrid Enforcer: The most versatile chess piece in the defense. Typically 6'0"-6'2", 200-220 lbs. Must have:

  - Linebacker instincts for run fits and diagnosing formations

  - Safety speed and man coverage ability for slot receivers and move TEs

  - Physical tackling to fill gaps and take on lead blockers

- Robber Technique: In coverage, reads the QB's eyes and "steals" throwing lanes on digs, curls, option routes, and shallow crossers. Against run, acts as a force player or scraping inside-out defender.

- Against 11 Personnel: This player often matches the slot receiver in man coverage or plays a "match" technique where they carry #2 vertical and drive on anything underneath. Against 12 personnel with inline TEs, they may walk down as a quasi-linebacker.

7. Rover / Star Strong Safeties (2 Players)

- The Constraint Solvers: These are your ultimate chess pieces. Pre-snap, they can show two-high shell, walk down to linebacker depth, align in the slot, or even stand on the edge as an extra rusher.

- Essential Man Coverage Ability: All strong safeties in this scheme must possess legitimate man coverage skills. They will be asked to:

  - Cover slot receivers in pure man coverage

  - Match vertical routes from #2 receivers in pattern-match concepts

  - Carry move TEs on seam routes and deep overs

  - Mirror running backs on wheel routes and option routes out of the backfield

- Multiple Functions:

  - Run Support: Fold into the box late (post-snap) to become the 6th/7th man, providing force/fill against inside/outside zone

  - Coverage: Drop to middle hook, play quarters, execute man coverage assignments, or match routes in pattern-matching schemes

  - Pressure: Blitz A/B-gaps from depth, creating "overload" looks the offensive line can't account for

- Modern Application: Against 11 personnel (the modern offensive base), these players turn your apparent light box into an 8-man front at the snap. By disguising their alignment and intention, they destroy the offense's pre-snap run/pass keys and create impossible blocking math.

Schematic Integrity: The "Wall and Spill" Philosophy

Why This IS a Modern Base Defense:

8. The NFL and college football have fundamentally shifted away from traditional power formations. The modern offensive landscape is dominated by:

- 11 personnel (1 RB, 1 TE, 3 WR) as the base package

- Move TEs who align in multiple spots and threaten vertically

- Slot receivers running option routes, crossers, and vertical concepts

- RPO integration forcing defenses to defend run and pass simultaneously

- Spread formations creating horizontal stress

9. The 3-2-6 Dime directly addresses this reality. It is not a "situational" defense but rather the base defense for the modern game. Traditional defenses with two linebackers (4-2-5, 4-3, 3-4) struggle because they either:

- Lack the speed to match 11 personnel in space

- Cannot generate enough coverage defenders without blitzing

- Get exposed by RPOs where linebackers trigger on run fakes and leave receivers uncovered

10. The "Wall" Concept (Interior Dominance)

Your 0-Tech and two DTs create a three-man "wall" across the A, B, and C gaps. By forcing the offensive line into man-blocking (rather than allowing easy combo blocks), you prevent clean releases to the second level. The offensive line is stuck blocking down linemen, which means pulling guards (rare in modern 11 personnel offenses) have to travel farther and your secondary has more time to fill.

Against modern inside zone concepts from 11 personnel, the wall forces the running back to press the line of scrimmage vertically before making a cut, buying time for your secondary to fill gaps.

11. The "Spill" Concept (Forcing Outside)

You intentionally funnel runs to the perimeter. The Joker/Buck players use "squeeze" technique (attacking the inside shoulder of the blocker) to force the ball carrier to bounce outside. Once the ball is outside, your Rovers/Stars (running downhill from depth with a head start) and your Big Nickel have angles to make tackles in space.

12. Key Principle: Modern offenses don't want to play smashmouth football. They want space, tempo, and mismatches. The 3-2-6 forces them to run between the tackles (where your wall lives) or outside (where your speed dominates). You are dictating terms, not reacting.

13. Creating the 8-Man Box Reality

Against 11 personnel, you actually have:

- 3 down linemen

- 2 hybrid edges (who can contain or rush)

- 1 Big Nickel (overhang/box safety)

- 2 Rovers (who fold down post-snap)

= 8 defenders at the point of attack

The modern offense cannot effectively run against 8-man boxes without significant personnel advantage. By disguising this as "dime," you bait the offense into running, then swarm with speed.

Dominance Against Modern 11 Personnel Offenses

14. Coverage Versatility Against Move TEs and Slot Receivers:

The rise of move TEs (think George Kittle, Travis Kelce, Brock Bowers) has broken traditional defenses. Linebackers are too slow. Traditional safeties aren't physical enough. The Big Nickel and Rovers in this scheme are specifically built to handle these players:

- Man coverage ability to carry them vertically

- Physicality to re-route and disrupt at the line

- Range to cover ground on crossers and deep overs

- Run-fit ability to not become a liability when the TE blocks

15. RPO Solutions:

RPOs die against this defense because:

- Your secondary players are in position to defend both run and pass

- The Robber can read the QB's eyes and drive on throws while maintaining run-gap integrity

- Pattern-matching allows you to carry vertical routes while still having defenders in run fits

- The disguise (two-high look that rotates to single-high) breaks the QB's pre-snap read

16. Pressure Without Blitzing:

The five-man line plus the ability to bring a Rover or Big Nickel from depth creates consistent pressure without sacrificing coverage. Against 11 personnel with five or six in protection, you can:

- Rush five and cover six (numerical advantage in coverage)

- Simulate pressure to force quick throws into robber coverage

- Bring delayed A-gap pressures that the center/guards cannot account for after sliding to the down linemen

Handling Heavier Personnel Groupings

17. Against 12 Personnel (1 RB, 2 TEs, 2 WR):

When offenses do bring a second tight end, you have options:

- Walk the Big Nickel or a Rover down to the line as a quasi-linebacker

- Joker/Buck players can handle inline TEs at the point of attack

- Your man coverage ability across the secondary allows you to match the TEs without sacrificing run fits

- The defense remains sound because the Rovers can still fold down to create an 8-man box

18. Against 21 Personnel (2 RB, 1 TE, 2 WR):

This personnel grouping is increasingly rare in modern football, but when it appears:

- Your front five can still control gaps (this is their bread and butter)

- The Big Nickel and both Rovers walk down, essentially playing as linebackers

- You maintain coverage ability on the outside with your two OCBs

- The scheme forces the offense to beat you with execution, not schematic advantage

The key insight: modern offenses don't stay in heavy personnel. They use 11 personnel 60-80% of the time. When they do go heavy, it's often a tell (run tendency), and your defense is still structurally sound with adjustments.

What Makes This Defense Succeed

19. Personnel Requirements:

1. Dominant 0-Tech: This player must consistently demand double-teams and hold the point of attack. Without this, the scheme fails.

2. Athletic DTs: Players who can two-gap when needed but also penetrate gaps and collapse the pocket. They must have lateral agility to handle reach blocks on outside zone.

3. Hybrid Edges with Coverage Ability: The Joker/Buck players must rush the passer, set the edge vs. run, and drop into coverage against move TEs. This is a rare skill set but essential.

4. Violent, Instinctive Secondary: Your DBs must be willing tacklers who diagnose quickly, fill gaps without hesitation, and shed blocks. All safeties must have legitimate man coverage skills.

5. Disguise and Communication: Pre-snap looks must confuse the offense. Post-snap execution requires all 11 players to understand their responsibilities in multiple coverages and fronts.

20. Schematic Advantages:

- Matches the modern offensive reality (11 personnel base)

- Creates numerical advantages in coverage (6 vs. 5 eligible receivers)

- Generates pressure without blitzing (keeping coverage intact)

- Destroys RPO concepts through pattern-matching and robber techniques

- Forces offenses to execute perfectly rather than exploiting schematic mismatches

Critical Vulnerabilities

21. What Can Exploit This Defense:

1. Gap Scheme Runs with Excellent Execution: If the offensive line executes outside zone or inside zone with perfect timing and your DL doesn't maintain gap integrity, cutback lanes can open. This requires your front to be disciplined and your secondary to fill immediately.

2. Power/Counter with Pulling Linemen: A pulling guard can create advantages if your Rovers don't scrape correctly or your front doesn't "wrong-arm" the puller. This is more a technique issue than a scheme flaw.

3. Sustained Heavy Personnel: If an offense commits to staying in 12 or 21 personnel for an entire drive, the physical nature of the game can wear down your lighter secondary. However, most modern offenses won't do this because they lose their tempo and constraint advantages.

4. Play-Action Deep Shots: Single-high safety with aggressive run-supporting DBs creates vulnerability to play-action vertical routes (posts, corners, deep overs). The FS must have elite range and the discipline to not bite on fakes.

5. Elite Offensive Line Play: If the offensive line consistently wins at the point of attack (driving the 0-Tech backward, sealing Joker/Buck players), the scheme breaks down. This is true of any defense but more pronounced here because your likely to lack traditional linebacker size to clean up mistakes.

22. Mitigation Strategies:

- Rotate coverages to show two-high on obvious play-action downs

- Bring a Rover into the box earlier against run-heavy tendencies

- Use line stunts and twists to prevent the offensive line from getting clean blocks

- Substitute personnel against sustained heavy packages (though this is rare in modern football)

Advanced Tactical Concepts

23. Gap Exchange Calls

Because you have five players on the line defending six gaps (A, A, B, B, C, C), you must have "exchange" calls where the DT and Joker/Buck swap responsibilities based on blocking scheme recognition:

- If the offense runs "down" scheme (tackle blocks down on the 5-tech DT), the DT "squeezes" inside to the B-gap while the Joker/Buck "scrapes" outside to take the C-gap.

- If the offense runs "base" blocking (man-to-man), everyone plays their primary gap.

- Against "reach" blocks on outside zone, the DTs must work laterally to prevent vertical displacement while the Joker/Buck sets a hard edge.

This requires elite film study, pre-snap communication, and post-snap reaction speed.

24. Pressure Packages from This Look

- Fire Zone Blitzes: Send six (both Joker/Buck + one Rover/Big Nickel blitzing) while playing zone behind it. Forces quick throws into robber coverage.

- Simulated Pressures: Show eight rushing pre-snap, drop four (Joker/Buck and Rovers drop into coverage), rush four. Destroys protection schemes and creates confusion.

- A-Gap Overloads: Both Rovers blitz inside A-gaps at the snap while the Big Nickel replaces one in coverage. The offensive line physically cannot block both without leaving the center isolated on the 0-Tech.

- Edge Pressures with Coverage: Send one Joker/Buck on a speed rush while dropping the other into the flat to take away hot routes. The QB sees "dime" and expects soft coverage but gets immediate pressure with tight windows.

25. Coverage Versatility

From this structure, you can seamlessly play:

- Cover 1 (man-free with FS over the top, ideal against 11 personnel)

- Cover 3 (3-deep, 4-under with Rovers in hook/curl zones)

- Cover 4 (quarters with both Rovers playing deep quarters against four verticals)

- Cover 2 (two-deep with Big Nickel/Rovers playing flat/curl)

- Pattern-Match Concepts (MatchQuarters principles where defenders carry #2 vertical and drive on anything underneath)

- Robber Coverage (Big Nickel reads QB eyes while everyone else plays man, destroys option routes)

This disguise element is why offenses struggle. They cannot predict coverage until post-snap, which slows down the QB's process and forces him into longer progressions (where your pass rush arrives).

Presentation-Ready Summary

26. Core Identity: The 3-2-6 Big Dime is the base defense for modern football. It is a positionless, hybrid-heavy scheme designed to match the reality that offenses operate primarily out of 11 personnel with spread formations, move tight ends, and RPO integration. It sacrifices traditional linebacker size for elite speed, coverage versatility, and pre-snap disguise.

27. Philosophical Foundation: Modern football is won in space, not in phone-booth collisions. The game has evolved away from fullbacks and toward athletes who can threaten defenses horizontally and vertically. This defense accepts that reality and builds a structure where speed, versatility, and disguise create advantages.

28. Strength Against Modern Offenses: 

- Dominant vs. 11 personnel (the modern offensive base)

- Handles move TEs and slot receivers through hybrid safeties with man coverage ability

- Destroys RPO concepts through pattern-matching and robber techniques

- Generates pressure without sacrificing coverage

- Creates 8-man box against run while maintaining coverage integrity

29. Handling Heavier Personnel: 

When offenses occasionally bring a second TE or RB, the scheme remains structurally sound. The Big Nickel and Rovers can walk down to create a traditional front, the Joker/Buck players handle inline TEs, and the coverage ability across the secondary allows for matchups without schematic stress. The reality is modern offenses rarely sustain heavy personnel because it eliminates their tempo and constraint advantages.

30. Critical Success Factors: 

Requires a dominant 0-Tech who can hold the point of attack, athletic DTs with gap discipline, hybrid edges who can rush and cover, and a secondary filled with violent tacklers who possess man coverage skills. All safeties must be able to cover slot receivers and move TEs in man coverage while also filling run gaps without hesitation.

31. Vulnerabilities: 

Susceptible to elite offensive line play (any defense is), gap-scheme runs if the front doesn't maintain discipline, and play-action vertical shots against single-high looks. Can be stressed by sustained heavy personnel (12/21), though this is increasingly rare in modern football.

Bottom Line

I keep coming back to this defense. This is not a gimmick or situational package. The 3-2-6 Big Dime is a legitimate base defense built for the modern game. It forces offenses to play on the defense's terms by matching their speed, overwhelming their protections, and creating coverage advantages that traditional defenses cannot achieve. It accepts that football has evolved and provides a structurally sound answer to that evolution.

Drake Maye's 2025 Season Development Assessment

Earlier this season I gave a scathing early to mid-season review of Drake Maye, arguing he hadn't improved enough from his college flaws through his rookie season, and predicting he was trending toward the bust/wash outcome I'd forecasted in my 2024 pre-draft analysis. Now Maye is in MVP conversations. So what are his persistent flaws, and how do they compare to my initial scouting report? Since I have obvious biases, let's examine what those who cover him professionally have said this season.

The Boston-area media outlets have highlighted several persistent flaws in Drake Maye's game during the 2025 NFL season, particularly related to his pocket management, accuracy on certain reads, and occasional turnover issues heading into the final regular season game before the Patriots' potential playoff run.

Drake Maye's 2025 Season Flaws

1. Holding the ball too long: Maye continues to hold onto the ball for extended periods, leading to a high sack total (he was sacked 44 times in 2024 and has been sacked 24 times through 17 games in 2025). Analysts have described him as sometimes drifting into pressure or even creating pressure himself through poor pocket movement, a concern that directly mirrors pre-draft evaluations about his "average pocket presence" and tendency to hold the ball.

2. Inaccuracy/Inconsistency in ball placement: In specific games, such as the matchup against the Bills, his accuracy and ball placement were notably off. Reports suggested he was not on the same page as his receivers, indicating either a lack of rapport or poor execution on both sides. This echoes pre-draft concerns about his "inconsistent accuracy" and tendency to miss open targets or sail sideline throws. His completion percentage has improved from 66.6% in 2024 to 67.5% in 2025, but inconsistency remains.

3. Struggles when moving past his first read: Maye's performance drops significantly when forced to progress beyond his primary target. He ranks fifth in DVOA on first-read throws but plummets to 22nd when moving to later reads. This directly validates the pre-draft scouting report warning that he "goes with the first read too often" and struggles to work through progressions, allowing defenders to read his eyes.

4. Occasional turnovers/Ball security: Despite general improvement from his rookie 2024 season (11 INTs, 5 fumbles lost) to 2025 (6 INTs through Week 17, 6 fumbles lost), he still commits occasional "boneheaded INTs" and loses fumbles. Critics have pointed to his turnover issues as an ongoing concern, reflecting the pre-draft evaluation that warned he "unnecessarily puts the ball in harm's way," forces throws, and makes "poor decisions."

5. Occasional sloppy footwork/fundamentals: Although Maye has shown improvement over the course of his two seasons, he still exhibits the footwork and fundamental issues that were evident during his college career at UNC, specifically the "inconsistent throwing mechanics/stances" and "inconsistent footwork" noted in pre-draft analysis.

2025 Statistical Overview (Through Week 17):

- Passing: 344 attempts, 232 completions (67.5%), 2,527 yards, 15 TDs, 6 INTs

- Rushing: 98 attempts, 409 yards (4.2 YPC), 2 TDs

- Sacks: 24 sacks taken

- Fumbles: 6 fumbles lost

- Rating: 87.7 passer rating

Conclusion on Developmental Progress

Based on coverage from CLNS, Boston Sports Journal, 98.5 The Sports Hub, NESN, NBC Boston, and Patriots.com, Drake Maye's primary flaws during the 2025 season remain largely mental and technical rather than physical, validating much of the original scouting assessment. The combination of issues points to developmental areas in field processing and pocket presence that were specifically flagged in the 2024 pre-draft evaluation.

Key areas requiring continued development:

- His tendency to hold the ball too long and take unnecessary sacks

- A significant drop in effectiveness when his first read is covered

- Inconsistent accuracy and ball placement under pressure

- Decision-making in complex defensive schemes

These have been the most frequently cited concerns throughout the 2025 season and align closely with the "bust" scenarios outlined in the original scouting report: inconsistent footwork leading to accuracy issues, locking onto receivers, questionable decision-making favoring big plays over smart plays, and struggles against more complex defenses.

Positive Signs:

Despite these persistent issues, media outlets have noted his ability to learn from mistakes and show overall improvement game-to-game. His athletic tools, arm strength, mobility, and ability to extend plays, remain elite when fundamentals are sound. His interception rate has improved (from 3.2% in 2024 to 1.7% in 2025), showing better ball security awareness. His rushing ability (409 yards, 4.2 YPC through Week 17) continues to add a valuable dimension to his game. The question entering the final regular season game and potential playoffs is whether he can minimize the mental errors and execute with consistency when the margin for error shrinks.

Context for the Original Scouting Report:

My 2024 pre-draft evaluation correctly identified Maye as a "boom or bust" prospect with "prototype build" and elite physical tools but significant developmental concerns. The assessment warned he would "need to sit a season minimum" and required extensive work on consistency, decision-making, and reading complex defenses.

After nearly two seasons (13 games in 2024, 17 games through Week 17 of 2025), many of those developmental concerns persist, though there's been incremental progress. The original comparisons remain relevant:

- Ceiling: Eli Manning - clutch performer with elite arm who overcame inconsistency (244 INTs, 125 Fumbles, 411 Sacks)

- Middle: Rob Johnson - big arm, athletic, but never put it together consistently (23 INTs, 14 Fumbles, 140 Sacks)

- Floor: Johnny Manziel - relied too much on improvisation, poor decisions (9 INTs, 9 Fumbles, 22 Sacks)

Maye currently sits somewhere between the middle and ceiling projections. The upcoming final regular season game and potential playoff appearance barring injury, will be crucial tests of whether his developmental trajectory continues upward toward the Manning ceiling or stalls closer to the Johnson middle ground, a talented quarterback whose mental processing never caught up to his physical gifts.

Now unlike myself, many other scouting reports I had read on Maye compared him to Josh Allen (Career: 94 INTs, 71 Fumbles, 229 Sacks). Allen when he was coming out of college was compared to Big Ben (Career 211 INTs, 115 Fumbles, 554 Sacks) and Brett Farve (Career: 336 INTs, 166 Fumbles, 525 Sacks), so essentially, the reports were comparing Maye to the two superbowl winners, that had a career of ball safety, sack, and just overall concerns throughout their careers. While I gave three more realistic options, so overall, Maye is and has been compared to 6 quarterbacks minimum with concerns throughout their career, that some made up for with talent, coaching, and players around them.

The pattern across all six of Maye's comparisons if were honest:

All six had big arms with velocity, Athletic/mobile for their size, held ball too long, forced throws into coverage, inconsistent accuracy under pressure, high sack totals, turnover-prone but capable of elite plays. Maye was okay but nothing special under Van Pelt and his simplistic west coast offense, with no guarantee he had a career. In 2025, he's been rescued by Josh McDaniels's mind and quarterback safety blanket offense.

The critical question remains:

Can Maye develop the consistent pre and post-snap processing, progression reading, and decision-making required to reach his ceiling, or will the mental side of the position continue to limit an otherwise elite physical talent? His statistical improvement in some areas (completion percentage up, interception rate down) suggests progress, but the persistent issues with sacks, progression reads, and consistency under pressure indicate significant developmental work remains.

Who am I:

I'm a Patriots blogger who correctly identified Drake Maye's developmental red flags in my 2024 pre-draft analysis. While he's now in MVP conversations, the same processing issues I flagged persist, and many beat writers covering him daily agree. My 2,000-word analysis examines whether Maye's improvement is real development or elite coaching masking fundamental flaws, using film analysis, advanced stats (DVOA), and historical QB comparisons.

I've always favored cerebral pocket passers over flashy athletic quarterbacks who rely on running ability and arm strength. I predicted Drake Maye would bust. Now he's in MVP talks, but I remain concerned. I credit Van Pelt and McDaniels for his success over his rookie and sophomore seasons; they've protected him with scheme. 'Fool's gold' is the best description I've heard about the 2025 Patriots, which I think currently fits Maye until he cleans up the five issues detailed above. And I'll stand by that even if he wins the MVP and or finishes the 2025 season with a superbowl ring.

Drake Maye: Mid 2025 Scouting Report

I gave an honest assessment of Drake Maye a few weeks ago (September 8th). I think it's time to re-evaluate the young quarterback. As of November 2025, Drake Maye has cemented his status as the New England Patriots' franchise quarterback, exhibiting significant growth and MVP-level production in his second season. After a turnover-prone rookie year in 2024, he has developed into a highly efficient and accurate passer while maintaining his elite athleticism as a runner. However, that's not the full story. That's where the mainstream analysis would have me stop.

2025 Season Statistics (as of Nov. 10)

Passing Yards: 2,555 
Passing Touchdowns: 19 
Passing Interceptions: 5 
Completion Percentage: 71.6% 
Quarterback Rating: 113.9 
Rushing Yards: 283 
Rushing Touchdowns: 2 
Fumbles: 6

Pros

As a passer, Maye has demonstrated elite passing ability, ranking among the league leaders in passing yards, touchdowns, and passer rating in 2025. He has significantly improved his deep-ball accuracy, posting a league-leading completion percentage on throws of 20+ yards. This season, he has also shown elite performance on third downs, ranking third in the NFL in passer rating.

As a runner, he possesses a dual-threat skill set with excellent athleticism, quickness, and speed. He is an explosive improviser and scrambler, with the ability to escape pressure and extend plays. The Patriots' new offensive scheme under Josh McDaniels is also utilizing his rushing ability with more designed runs in 2025.

Growth potential remains high. Observers note his immense growth from his rookie year, with his flashes of brilliance now becoming a more consistent reality. His continued development could see him reach All-Pro caliber.

The supporting cast has improved dramatically. The addition of a new offensive coordinator, improved offensive line, and new weapons like Stefon Diggs and Kyle Williams have contributed to his success.

Cons

Turnover issues persist. While his 2025 interception total is lower than his rookie season, Maye still has six fumbles through 10 games, continuing to raise concerns about ball security.

Decision-making remains inconsistent. The turnovers highlight lapses in judgment and a lingering tendency to play hero ball, particularly when extending plays. As in his rookie season, he can still make ill-advised deep throws under pressure.

Pocket presence, while improved, still needs refinement. His processing under pressure still needs to get steadier, as indicated by his occasional poor ball security when forced off his spot.

Consistency is an ongoing concern. His inexperience still shows up at times, and he occasionally lapses into sloppy mechanics, resulting in inaccurate throws.

Decision-Making: Then and Now

Drake Maye's decision-making has seen a marked improvement in 2025, but it remains an area for refinement.

Rookie year 2024 saw pronounced struggles with decision-making, leading to 16 total turnovers: 10 interceptions and 6 lost fumbles in 12 starts. A notable example was a game-ending interception in overtime against the Titans.

Second season 2025 shows progress. He has reduced his interception total to 5 through 10 games, demonstrating better field vision and anticipation. However, his 6 fumbles this season indicate that ball security issues under pressure persist. Some of these are from holding onto the ball too long, which he still needs to address.

What's Changed

Interceptions have dropped significantly. From 10 in his rookie year, he's now on pace for approximately 6-7 this season. He's cutting the most catastrophic errors.

Completion percentage has jumped to 71.6 percent. In Week 1 alone, I noted 8 accuracy issues. That problem has largely been solved.

Deep ball accuracy now leads the league. On throws of 20-plus yards, Maye ranks first in completion percentage. My draft profile flagged inconsistent accuracy and sailing sideline throws as major concerns.

Third down performance ranks third in the NFL in passer rating. This addresses the pre-draft concern about making adjustments after the snap.

Volume and production are legitimate top-tier numbers. Through 10 games, 2,555 yards and 19 touchdowns represent genuine franchise quarterback production.

What Hasn't Changed

Fumbles remain a persistent problem. He lost 7 of 11 fumbles in college. Now he has 6 fumbles through 10 games in 2025, still on pace for 9-10 this season. The ball security issue has not been resolved.

Hero ball decision-making continues. My draft profile warned about risk-taking, forcing throws, and unnecessarily putting the ball in harm's way. In Week 1, I observed him throwing to tight or covered targets too often. The November 2025 scouting report still notes lapses in judgment and a tendency to play hero ball when extending plays.

Holding the ball too long was flagged in the draft profile. The 6 fumbles suggest it's still happening under pressure.

Inconsistent mechanics persist. The draft profile noted inconsistent throwing mechanics and stances. The November 2025 report states he occasionally lapses into sloppy mechanics, resulting in inaccurate throws.

Processing under pressure still needs work. This remains consistent with draft concerns about poor throws under pressure.

Bottom Line: What's the Story?

The passing results have improved dramatically. Fewer picks, better accuracy, elite production. These are real gains that cannot be dismissed.

But the underlying tendencies that concerned me remain present. Ball security, forcing plays, inconsistent technique are still part of his game. He's playing better, but he hasn't fundamentally changed who he is as a quarterback.

Maye is a pocket quarterback who can run, similar to Eli Manning's semi-mobile profile (although some would have me say Josh Allen) rather than a true dual-threat like Michael Vick. The comparison holds because both show stretches of brilliant production mixed with maddening inconsistency. The talent is undeniable. The question is whether the infrastructure around him can continue compensating for the flaws, or whether those flaws will surface in critical moments when it matters most.

For now, the Patriots appear to have their franchise quarterback. Whether they have their championship quarterback remains to be seen. Yes, I admit I have a little bias as I prefer the cerebral Montana, Brady, Pennington pocket quarterback over the circus style of quarterbacks like Mahomes, Vick, or Lamar Jackson. Fundementals as a passer will always be more important than athleticism for a quarterback.

Concept of the Five Terrors (5-Tight-End) Offense: A Blueprint for Jumbo Hybrid Power-Spread in the NFL

Introduction: The Problem With Modern NFL Offense

The modern NFL defense has evolved into a faster, lighter, coverage-oriented system designed to combat the pass-heavy offenses that dominate the league. Defenses routinely deploy nickel and dime packages, prioritizing speed over size, athleticism over power, and coverage ability over run-stopping physicality. This defensive philosophy has created a fundamental vulnerability. By committing to smaller personnel to defend the pass, modern defenses have sacrificed their ability to defend physical, power-based offenses that attack with size, mass, and leverage at the point of attack.

The solution is not to build another pass-first spread offense that plays into the hands of these coverage-heavy defenses. The solution is to build an offense that exploits the inherent weaknesses of modern defensive construction by forcing defenses into an impossible choice: stay light and fast to cover, and get demolished in the run game, or substitute into heavier personnel to stop the run, and get exploited in coverage by athletic mismatches. This is the Five Terrors offense.

The Five Terrors offense is a jumbo hybrid power-spread system built around five tight ends. It is not a goal-line package. It is not a short-yardage gimmick. It is a complete, four-down offensive system capable of sustaining drives, controlling the clock, scoring points, and winning championships. The offense operates from a base personnel grouping of one quarterback, five offensive linemen, and five tight ends. No running backs. No wide receivers. Just eleven players who can block, catch, run, and create mismatches that defenses cannot solve.

This offense forces defenses to choose. If the defense stays in nickel or dime, the offense runs power football with seven, eight, or even nine blockers at the point of attack and physically dominates lighter defensive fronts. If the defense substitutes into base or goal-line personnel to stop the run, the offense spreads four tight ends wide, creating impossible coverage matchups where 250-pound athletes with sub-4.8 speed run routes against linebackers and safeties who cannot keep up. The defense cannot win. The offense dictates terms.

This is not a dream. This is an offense waiting for the right mind to build it.

The Core Concept: Deception Through Personnel Ambiguity

The foundation of the Five Terrors offense is simple: create systematic deception by using personnel that can align in multiple formations and execute multiple roles without substituting. The five tight ends can align in a traditional jumbo formation with all five on the line of scrimmage, creating a power-run look that suggests the offense is running downhill. On the very next snap, without changing personnel, four of those tight ends can spread wide into a trips or quads formation, creating a pass-heavy look that forces the defense into coverage mode. The offense can even go empty, spreading all five tight ends across the formation with no one in the backfield, creating a pure pass look that forces the defense to cover in space. The offense can shift from a 7-man protection pass play to a 9-man gap scheme run play to an empty formation quick passing attack, all without the defense knowing which is coming until the ball is snapped.

This creates systematic deception at a level that no other offensive system can achieve. Traditional offenses telegraph their intentions through personnel. When an offense brings in 21 personnel with two running backs and one tight end, the defense knows the run is coming and adjusts accordingly. When an offense brings in 10 personnel with four wide receivers, the defense knows the pass is coming and adjusts accordingly. The Five Terrors offense eliminates this predictability entirely. The same eleven players can run power, run zone, pass from play-action, pass from empty, run RPOs, or execute screens, all without substituting. The defense cannot adjust because they do not know what is coming.

The key to this deception is motion. The offense uses pre-snap motion on nearly every play to force the defense to reveal their coverage, identify their Mike linebacker, and expose their vulnerabilities. The H-back, a hybrid tight end who aligns in the backfield and serves as the primary running back, can motion across the formation to create overloads, force defensive adjustments, and identify man or zone coverage. The Move/Flex tight ends, who align on the line or in the slot, can motion into the backfield, creating the illusion of a traditional I-formation or offset backfield. The offense can show a heavy run look, then motion into a spread look or an empty look, all in the three seconds before the snap. The defense cannot keep up.

This is not just about confusing the defense. This is about breaking their ability to identify the offensive structure, set their front, and execute their assignments. In a traditional offense, the defense can identify the running back, the tight ends, and the wide receivers, and assign defenders accordingly. In the Five Terrors offense, every player is a tight end. Every player can block, catch, or run. The defense cannot identify who is doing what until the ball is snapped, and by then it is too late.

Why This Offense Works Against Modern Defenses

Modern NFL defenses are built around a few core principles. They prioritize speed and coverage ability over size and physicality. They deploy nickel and dime packages to defend the pass. They use smaller linebackers who can cover running backs and tight ends in space. They rely on defensive backs to support the run from the second level. The Five Terrors offense is specifically designed to exploit every single one of these principles.

Against nickel and dime packages, the offense wins immediately in the run game. Modern nickel defenses typically have four down linemen, two linebackers, and five defensive backs. Against a Five Terrors offense running a power scheme with seven blockers at the point of attack, the defense is out-numbered and out-sized. The offense has five offensive linemen and two in-line tight ends blocking at the point of attack, with the H-back running as the primary ball carrier through the hole. The defense has four defensive linemen and maybe one linebacker in the box. The math does not work. The offense wins the numbers game and the size game, and the result is consistent four, five, and six-yard runs that move the chains and wear down the defense.

Against base defenses, the offense wins immediately in the pass game. If the defense substitutes out of nickel and into base or goal-line personnel to stop the run, the offense checks into a spread formation or an empty formation. Four or five tight ends flex wide, creating a trips, quads, or empty look. The defense is now forced to cover four or five athletic 250-pound tight ends running routes with linebackers, strong safeties, or even defensive linemen who cannot keep up. The offense runs play-action, the linebackers bite on the run fake, and the tight ends run seam routes, post routes, and crossers into wide-open space. The defense cannot cover. The offense completes pass after pass for ten, fifteen, twenty yards until the defense is forced to substitute back into nickel, at which point the offense checks back into the run game.

Against blitzes, the offense wins with both protection and quick passing. If a defense wants to send five or six rushers after the quarterback, they are leaving themselves at a disadvantage. With five tight ends who can all block, the offense can protect with seven, eight, or even nine blockers, neutralizing the blitz and giving the quarterback time. But the offense does not have to use maximum protection. The offense can also go empty, spreading all five tight ends wide and running a quick passing game. If the defense sends six rushers, they only have five defenders in coverage against five receivers. The math favors the offense. The quarterback identifies the hot route pre-snap, gets the ball out in under two seconds, and the tight end catches the ball in space with only one defender to beat. The defense cannot generate pressure without giving up easy completions. The offense controls the game.

Using RPOs, the offense uses the threat of the run to create easy completions in the pass game. The offensive line run blocks, the H-back runs through the hole, and the quarterback reads the leverage of the overhang defender, typically a strong safety or outside linebacker. If the defender steps down to stop the run, the quarterback throws a quick pass to a tight end running a slant or a flat route. If the defender drops into coverage, the quarterback hands the ball off and the offense runs power with seven blockers against a light box. The defense is always wrong. The offense is always right.

Using tempo, the offense does not substitute. The same eleven players are on the field for every snap. The defense cannot substitute without risking a delay of game penalty or being caught with the wrong personnel. If the offense runs a play that gains seven yards, they hurry to the line and snap the ball before the defense can adjust. The defense is gassed. The offense is in control.

Using max protection, the offense protects the quarterback with seven, eight, or even nine blockers when needed. The quarterback does not need to scramble because he has time to throw. The offense can run max protection on passing plays and still have two, three, or four receivers running routes. The quarterback stays in the pocket, manipulates the pocket by stepping up or sliding left or right, and delivers accurate throws to tight ends running intermediate routes. The defense cannot generate pressure. The quarterback is comfortable.

The Five Terrors offense is not just a run offense. It is not just a pass offense. It is a complete offense that exploits every weakness of the modern defense without compromise.

Historical Precedent: The Genesis of the H-Back and the Patriots' Four Tight End Set

The Five Terrors offense is not a radical departure from football history. It is an evolution of successful offensive philosophies that have been proven to work at the highest level. The most important historical precedent is the two-tight-end offense popularized by Joe Gibbs with the Washington Redskins in the 1980s. Gibbs faced a problem. His offense was being destroyed by Lawrence Taylor, the most dominant defensive player in NFL history. Taylor was too fast for offensive tackles to block, too strong for running backs to chip, and too smart to be schemed around with traditional formations. Gibbs needed a solution.

Gibbs' solution was to create the H-back position. He moved a tight end or fullback off the line of scrimmage and aligned him in the backfield, giving him the flexibility to motion, lead block, pass protect, or release into routes. This player, the H-back, was bigger and stronger than a running back, capable of handling Lawrence Taylor's blitzes and edge pressure. He was also athletic enough to run routes and catch passes, creating a mismatch against linebackers who were too slow to cover him. The H-back was the genesis of positional ambiguity. He was not a tight end. He was not a fullback. He was not a running back. He was all three, and defenses could not adjust.

The Five Terrors offense takes this concept and scales it to the extreme. Instead of one H-back, the offense has five tight ends, all of whom can play the H-back role. Instead of two tight ends, the offense has five. Instead of creating one mismatch, the offense creates five mismatches on every play. The philosophy is the same. The execution is magnified.

The second historical precedent is the New England Patriots' use of multiple tight end sets under Josh McDaniels and Tom Brady. The Patriots routinely deployed two-tight-end sets with Rob Gronkowski and Aaron Hernandez, creating impossible matchups for defenses. Gronkowski was a 265-pound in-line blocker who could seal the edge in the run game and win contested catches in the pass game. Hernandez was a 245-pound move tight end who could align in the slot, run routes like a wide receiver, and create separation against linebackers and safeties. The Patriots used motion to disguise their intentions, running power with both tight ends blocking or spreading them wide and throwing to mismatches.

The Patriots also experimented with three-tight-end and even four-tight-end sets. In goal-line situations, the Patriots would bring in four tight ends, creating a jumbo formation that suggested a power run. The defense would substitute into goal-line personnel, expecting the run. The Patriots would then throw a quick pass to one of the tight ends leaking out into the flat or running a seam route, scoring an easy touchdown against a defense that was out-positioned. The Patriots understood that tight ends created systematic deception because they could block and catch, and defenses could not adjust fast enough to defend both.

The Five Terrors offense takes this concept one step further. The Patriots ran a four-tight-end set situationally. The Five Terrors offense runs a five-tight-end set as a base. If the Patriots had added an H-back to their four-tight-end set, they would have had a five-tight-end offense. This offense is that concept, fully realized and executed as a complete system.

The philosophical connection to the McDaniels-Brady Patriots offense is critical. That offense required elite mental processing, precise execution, and the ability to adjust at the line of scrimmage based on defensive alignment. The quarterback and the offense operated as one mind, checking into the correct play, identifying the Mike linebacker, and exploiting the defense's weakness. The Five Terrors offense requires the same level of mental toughness and cognitive excellence. The quarterback must process the defense pre-snap, identify the coverage, check into the correct play, and execute without hesitation. One mental mistake, one blown assignment, one missed adjustment, and the entire scheme collapses. The margin for error is razor-thin.

The Run Game: Power, Deception, and Physical Dominance

The primary identity of the Five Terrors offense is power football. The offense is built to run the ball with overwhelming force, using superior numbers and leverage at the point of attack to physically dominate the defense. The run game is built around three core concepts: Power, Counter, and Zone. These concepts are executed with multiple tight ends serving as lead blockers, pullers, and edge setters, creating a physical mismatch that lighter defenses cannot stop.

The Power concept is the foundation of the offense. The offense aligns with two in-line tight ends on one side, creating a strong side overload. The offensive line down blocks, with the playside guard and tackle blocking down on the defensive linemen. The backside guard pulls through the hole, leading for the H-back who is running as the primary ball carrier. The two in-line tight ends on the playside seal the edge, preventing the defense from flowing outside. The result is a seven-man surface at the point of attack, with blockers outnumbering defenders and creating a crease for the H-back to run through. Against a nickel defense with only five or six players in the box, this play gains five yards every time.

The H-back is the workhorse running back of this offense. This is not a player who occasionally carries the ball. This is the primary ball carrier, the player who will touch the ball fifteen to twenty times per game, the player who grinds out yards between the tackles and wears down the defense. The H-back must run with power, break tackles, and consistently gain four to five yards per carry. The H-back is a John Riggins-style bruiser, a Keith Byars-style utility back, a Mike Alstott-style power runner, a Larry Centers receiving back, and a James Devlin blocking back. The H-back is the engine of the offense.

The Counter concept adds deception to the power run game. The offense shows a run to one side, with the H-back motioning across the formation to create the illusion of a strong side run. At the snap, the offensive line pulls in the opposite direction, with the backside guard and tight end pulling around the edge to lead block. The H-back cuts back against the flow, running through the hole created by the pulling blockers. The defense flows to the initial run fake, leaving the backside undefended. The H-back runs into open space for a big gain. This play is particularly effective against aggressive defenses that over-pursue to the ball.

The Counter Slice concept is a variation of Counter that uses a tight end to execute a slice block on the backside defensive end, preventing him from penetrating and disrupting the play. The slice block is executed by a Move/Flex tight end who aligns on the backside, takes a flat angle across the formation, and blocks the defensive end at the line of scrimmage. This block seals the backside, allowing the pulling blockers to get around the edge and lead the H-back through the hole. The Counter Slice is a high-efficiency play that consistently gains yards because it creates a numbers advantage and eliminates the backside pursuit.

The Zone concept is used to create horizontal stretch on the defense and attack the perimeter. The offensive line and tight ends execute zone steps, moving laterally to the playside and blocking the defenders in their zone. The H-back reads the blocking and cuts upfield through the first available crease. The Zone concept is effective against defenses that stack the box because it forces defenders to move laterally and creates cutback lanes for the H-back. The offense can also run Zone out of spread formations, flexing tight ends wide to create horizontal space and forcing the defense to defend the entire width of the field.

The run game is enhanced by pre-snap motion. The H-back motions across the formation on nearly every play, forcing the defense to adjust and revealing their coverage. If the defense is in man coverage, a defender will follow the H-back across the formation. If the defense is in zone coverage, the defenders will shift but not follow. The quarterback identifies the coverage and checks into the correct play. If the defense is in man coverage, the offense runs a play-action pass. If the defense is in zone coverage, the offense runs power. The defense is always reacting. The offense is always in control.

The Pass Game: Play-Action, Quick Passing, and Mismatch Exploitation

The Five Terrors offense is not a run-only system. The pass game is a critical component of the offense, designed to exploit the defense's aggression against the run and create mismatches in coverage. The pass game is built around four principles: play-action, quick passing from empty, intermediate routes, and maximum protection. These principles allow the offense to attack defenses that commit to stopping the run, creating explosive plays and keeping the defense honest.

The play-action pass is the most important concept in the offense. Because the run game is so physical and effective, defenses are forced to commit extra defenders to the box to stop it. When the offense shows a run look with two in-line tight ends and an H-back in the backfield, the defense expects a run. The offensive line run blocks, the H-back takes a step toward the line as if he is carrying the ball, and the defense reacts. Linebackers step up to fill gaps. Safeties move toward the line of scrimmage. The secondary loses depth. At this moment, the quarterback play-fakes the handoff, the tight ends release into routes, and the offense attacks the space vacated by the defense. The linebackers are caught flat-footed. The safeties are too close to the line. The tight ends are running wide open.

The primary play-action concept is the Drift or Swirl. In this concept, the tight ends align in condensed formations, close to the offensive line. At the snap, they take a quick step outside as if they are blocking, then break sharply inside and run crossing routes through the middle of the field. The quarterback executes a hard play-fake, the linebackers bite on the fake, and the tight ends drift across the formation into the holes in the zone coverage. The quarterback delivers the ball to the open tight end for a gain of ten to fifteen yards. This play works because the defense is so focused on stopping the run that they cannot react fast enough to the crossing routes.

The second critical concept is the Tight End Leak. This play is executed off a Wide Zone run fake. The offensive line executes zone steps to the playside, creating the illusion of a zone run. One of the in-line tight ends executes a convincing run block on the playside defensive end, engaging him for one or two seconds. Then the tight end releases from the block and leaks across the formation on a shallow crossing route. The offensive line uses a specialized protection scheme called Center Lag, where the center takes a run step before spinning out to protect the backside C-gap. This protection keeps the quarterback clean while the tight end leaks into open space. The quarterback delivers the ball to the leaking tight end for a high-percentage completion and a significant gain. This play systematically converts the defense's aggression against the run into an easy completion.

The third concept is the Empty Quick Passing Game. This is where the offense truly exploits the modern defense's vulnerability to blitzes. The offense goes empty, spreading all five tight ends across the formation with no one in the backfield. The defense sees the empty formation and often responds by bringing pressure, sending five or six rushers to get to the quarterback before he can deliver the ball. But the offense is ready. With five 250-pound tight ends who can all block, the offense has multiple options. They can keep tight ends in to block, creating seven-man or eight-man protection against five or six rushers. Or they can release all five tight ends into routes, creating five-on-five or five-on-four coverage situations where the tight ends have size and leverage advantages against defensive backs.

The beauty of the empty quick passing game is the math. If the defense sends six rushers, they only have five defenders in coverage. The quarterback identifies the hot route pre-snap based on which defender is blitzing, gets the ball out in under two seconds, and the tight end catches the ball with only one defender to beat. With so many big players who can block and catch, the defense faces an impossible choice. If they blitz, they give up easy completions. If they drop into coverage, the quarterback has time to find the open receiver. The defense cannot win.

The empty formation also creates massive advantages in the quick passing game because the tight ends are running routes from space rather than having to release from the line of scrimmage. Slants, hitches, and quick outs become high-percentage throws that gain consistent yardage. The tight ends are too big for cornerbacks to jam at the line, too fast for linebackers to stay with, and too physical for safeties to tackle in space. The empty quick passing game is a devastating weapon against blitz-happy defenses.

The fourth concept is the Seam Route. This is a vertical attack designed to exploit single-high safety defenses. The offense spreads four tight ends wide, creating a trips or quads formation. The Move/Flex tight ends run vertical seam routes up the field, attacking the space between the cornerbacks and the free safety. The quarterback reads the safety's leverage and throws to the tight end who has the best angle. Because the tight ends are 250 pounds and running sub-4.8 speed, they create size and speed mismatches against safeties who are too small to defend them physically and cornerbacks who are too slow to run with them vertically. The seam route is a high-risk, high-reward concept that creates explosive plays when executed correctly.

The pass game is enhanced by maximum protection when needed. Because the offense has five tight ends, it can always protect with seven, eight, or even nine blockers. This protection ensures that the quarterback is never under pressure and has time to go through his progressions and deliver accurate throws. The protection is built around the five offensive linemen, two in-line tight ends who stay in to block, and the H-back who can chip the edge rusher before releasing into a route or staying in to block. This seven-man protection is the baseline. The offense can add an eighth blocker by keeping a Move/Flex tight end in to block, or a ninth blocker by keeping two Move/Flex tight ends in. This maximum protection neutralizes blitzes, eliminates pressure, and gives the quarterback all day to throw.

The pass game is not designed to create explosive plays primarily through vertical speed. The offense isn't expected to have wide receivers who can run 4.4 forties and stretch the field vertically. Instead, the pass game creates explosive plays through deception, leverage, and mismatches. The offense uses play-action to freeze the defense, empty formations to create quick passing opportunities, intermediate routes to attack the vacated space, and athletic tight ends to win physical matchups. The result is a high-efficiency pass game that consistently converts third downs, moves the chains, and keeps drives alive.

Personnel Requirements: The Players Who Make It Work

The Five Terrors offense requires specific types of players. These are not traditional position players. These are hybrid athletes who can do multiple things at a competent level. The goal is not to field an offense of All-Pros. The goal is to field an offense of versatile, intelligent, high-effort players who fit the scheme. Below are the exact specifications for each position, including ideal physical measurements, required abilities, and the role each player fills within the offense.

Quarterback (The Cerebral Assassin)

The quarterback in the Five Terrors offense is not a traditional dual-threat quarterback who scrambles for yards. The quarterback is a pocket manipulator and a decision maker. The job is to process the defense pre-snap, identify the coverage, check into the correct play, execute the snap, and deliver the ball on time and on target. The quarterback must have elite pocket presence, the ability to step up, slide, and drift within the pocket to reset throwing lanes and avoid pressure. The quarterback must have quick processing speed to execute RPOs and read play-action developments. The quarterback must be able to throw with anticipation, delivering the ball before the receiver breaks open.

Ideal physical measurements: Height between 6 feet 2 inches and 6 feet 6+ inches. Weight between 220 and 250 pounds. The quarterback must have enough size to see over the offensive line and absorb hits in the pocket. Mobility is not a primary requirement, but the quarterback should be able to move within the pocket and pick up a first down on third-and-short if necessary.

Required abilities: Elite pre-snap processing. The quarterback must be able to identify the Mike linebacker, recognize the coverage, and check into the correct play in the three seconds before the snap. Pocket presence and manipulation. The quarterback must be able to step up into the pocket, slide left or right, and drift backward to reset throwing lanes without leaving the tackle box. Quick decision making. The quarterback must be able to execute RPOs, read play-action fakes, and deliver the ball quickly on empty formations and quick passing concepts. Accuracy on intermediate throws. The quarterback does not need to throw deep constantly, but must be able to deliver accurate throws on crossing routes, seam routes, and intermediate posts. Leadership and communication. The quarterback is the leader of the offense and must communicate with the offensive line, tight ends, and coaches to ensure everyone is on the same page.

Role in the Five Terrors offense: The quarterback is the decision engine. Pre-snap, the quarterback identifies the defense's structure, recognizes the coverage, and checks into the correct play. Post-snap, the quarterback executes the play, reads the defense, and delivers the ball to the open receiver. The quarterback does not need to make plays with his legs. The quarterback makes plays with his mind.

Why the quarterback is critical: The offense requires constant pre-snap adjustments and post-snap reads. If the quarterback cannot process the defense and check into the correct play, the offense will run into bad matchups and the scheme will fail. The quarterback must be the smartest player on the field.

Player molds: Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Philip Rivers, Matt Ryan, Kirk Cousins, Chad Pennington, Mac Jones. These are pocket passers who process defenses at an elite mental level, manipulate the pocket, and deliver accurate throws. The offense needs a quarterback who plays like Tom Brady in the McDaniels system: intelligent, precise, and in control.

Offensive Line (The Anchor)

The offensive line is the foundation of the offense. Their job is to create push in the run game, sustain blocks on zone schemes, and protect the quarterback in the pass game. The offensive line must be physical, powerful, and technically sound. The offensive line does not need to be elite athletes. They need to be competent blockers who can execute their assignments and maintain leverage.

Ideal physical measurements: Height between 6 feet 3 inches and 6 feet 6 inches. Weight between 300 and 330 pounds. The offensive line must have enough size and mass to create push in the run game and anchor in pass protection.

Required abilities: Drive blocking. The offensive line must be able to create vertical push in the run game, driving defenders off the line of scrimmage. Zone blocking. The offensive line must be able to execute zone steps, moving laterally and blocking defenders in their zone. Pass protection. The offensive line must be able to anchor in pass protection, sustaining blocks for three to four seconds to give the quarterback time to throw. Communication. The offensive line must communicate blocking assignments, identify stunts and blitzes, and adjust protection schemes.

Role in the Five Terrors offense: The offensive line creates push in the run game and protects the quarterback in the pass game. They are the anchor of the offense.

Why the offensive line is critical: If the offensive line cannot create push in the run game, the entire offense collapses. The run game is the foundation, and the offensive line must execute.

Player molds: Traditional offensive linemen who excel in power schemes. The offense needs a line that plays like the Dallas Cowboys' offensive line in the 1990s: physical, powerful, and dominant.

In-Line Tight End (The Anchor, Two Players)

The in-line tight end is the primary blocker on the edge. This player aligns on the line of scrimmage, either as a traditional Y tight end or flexed outside as a wing. The in-line tight end must be a dominant blocker who can seal the edge in the run game and protect the quarterback in the pass game. The in-line tight end must also be a competent receiver who can catch passes on play-action and run blocking routes.

Ideal physical measurements: Height between 6 feet 4 inches and 6 feet 7 inches. Weight between 250 and 270+ pounds. The in-line tight end must have enough size and mass to seal the edge and sustain blocks against defensive ends and outside linebackers.

Required abilities: Elite blocking. The in-line tight end must be able to down block, seal the edge, and sustain blocks on defensive ends. Physical receiving. The in-line tight end must be able to catch passes in traffic, win contested catches, and block after the catch. Line-of-scrimmage anchor. The in-line tight end must be able to align on the line and create a physical presence at the point of attack.

Role in the Five Terrors offense: The in-line tight end is the edge anchor. In the run game, they seal the edge and prevent defenders from flowing outside. In the pass game, they protect the quarterback or release into short routes.

Why the in-line tight end is critical: If the in-line tight ends cannot seal the edge, the run game will fail. The offense needs physical blockers who can dominate the point of attack.

Player molds: Rob Gronkowski, Mark Bavaro, Dallas Clark when blocking, George Kittle when blocking. These are physical, dominant blockers who can also catch passes.

Move/Flex Tight End (The Creator, Two Players)

The Move/Flex tight end is the athlete of the offense. This player aligns in the slot, on the line, or in the backfield, and creates mismatches with speed and route running. The Move/Flex tight end must be fast enough to run routes like a wide receiver, physical enough to block linebackers, and versatile enough to align in multiple positions. The ideal Move/Flex tight end is a 230 to 250-pound athlete who runs a sub-4.8 forty-yard dash.

Ideal physical measurements: Height between 6 feet 4 inches and 6 feet 7 inches. Weight between 230 and 250 pounds. The Move/Flex tight end must have enough size to block and enough speed to create separation. A 40-yard dash time under 4.8 seconds is ideal, with sub-4.7 being elite for this role.

Required abilities: Route running. The Move/Flex tight end must be able to run the full route tree, including crossing routes, seam routes, and vertical routes. Speed mismatches. The Move/Flex tight end must be fast enough to create separation against linebackers and safeties. Vertical threat. The Move/Flex tight end must be able to stretch the field vertically and win on deep routes. Competent blocking. The Move/Flex tight end does not need to be an elite blocker, but must be able to block defensive backs and chip edge rushers.

Role in the Five Terrors offense: The Move/Flex tight end creates mismatches in the pass game and provides flexibility in the run game. They can align wide, in the slot, or in the backfield, and the defense cannot adjust.

Why the Move/Flex tight end is critical: The Move/Flex tight end is the mismatch creator. If the offense does not have fast, athletic tight ends, the pass game will struggle and the defense will stack the box against the run.

Player molds: Aaron Hernandez, Vernon Davis in his prime, Kyle Pitts, Darren Waller (receiver convert), Jimmy Graham. These are athletic tight ends who can run routes and create separation.

H-Back (The Running Back, One Player)

The H-back is the most unique and most important player in the offense. This player is not just a hybrid or a utility player. This player is the running back of the Five Terrors offense. The H-back aligns in the backfield, motions across the formation, leads blocks on power runs, and serves as the primary ball carrier. The H-back will touch the ball fifteen to twenty times per game, grinding out yards between the tackles and wearing down the defense. The H-back must be physical enough to block defensive ends, tough enough to run between the tackles and break tackles, and versatile enough to catch passes out of the backfield.

Ideal physical measurements: Height between 6 feet 2 inches and 6 feet 5+ inches. Weight between 230 and 260 pounds. The H-back must have enough size to block and deliver punishment as a runner, and enough speed to consistently gain yards. A 40-yard dash time under 4.8 seconds is ideal.

Required abilities: Power running. The H-back must be able to run between the tackles, break tackles, and consistently gain four to five yards per carry. Lead blocking. The H-back must be able to lead through the hole as a fullback, blocking linebackers and safeties. Runner vision. The H-back must be able to read blocks, find creases, and make decisive cuts. Fullback and runner hybrid. The H-back must combine the physicality of a fullback with the vision and toughness of a power running back. Receiving ability. The H-back must be able to catch passes out of the backfield and run routes in the flat or on wheel routes.

Role in the Five Terrors offense: The H-back is the running back and the lead blocker. In the run game, the H-back carries the ball on power runs, counter runs, and zone runs, or leads through the hole as a fullback when another tight end is carrying the ball on trick plays. In the pass game, the H-back protects the quarterback or releases into short routes.

Why the H-back is critical: The H-back is the engine of the offense. This player must be a workhorse who can carry the ball twenty times per game and consistently move the chains. Without a physical, tough H-back who can run with power and lead block, the offense cannot establish the run. This is the John Riggins of the offense, the Keith Byars, the Mike Alstott, the Larry Centers, the James Devlin. This is the running back.

Player molds: John Riggins, Keith Byars, Mike Alstott, Larry Centers, Kyle Juszczyk when used as a primary ball carrier, C.J. Ham. These are physical, versatile players who can block, run with power, and catch. The H-back must embody the toughness and physicality of these players while serving as the primary running back of the offense.

Offensive Philosophy: The Substitution Game and the Incompatibility Crisis

The Five Terrors offense wins by forcing the defense into an incompatibility crisis. Modern NFL defenses are built to defend the pass. They deploy nickel and dime packages with five or six defensive backs on the field, sacrificing size and physicality for speed and coverage ability. The Five Terrors offense exploits this construction by presenting a heavy personnel grouping that forces the defense to choose between two bad options.

Option one: the defense stays in nickel or dime. If the defense stays in their preferred light personnel, the offense runs power football with overwhelming force. With seven, eight, or nine blockers at the point of attack, the offense physically dominates the lighter defensive front. The defense cannot stop the run. The offense gains four, five, six yards per carry. The defense is worn down over the course of the game. The offense controls the clock, sustains drives, and scores points.

Option two: the defense substitutes into base or goal-line personnel. If the defense substitutes into heavier personnel to stop the run, the offense checks into a spread formation or an empty formation. Four or five tight ends flex wide, creating a trips, quads, or empty look. The defense is now forced to cover four or five athletic 250-pound tight ends with linebackers, strong safeties, or defensive linemen who cannot keep up. The offense runs play-action or quick passes from empty. The linebackers bite on the run fake or cannot cover in space. The tight ends run seam routes into wide-open space or catch quick passes for easy completions. The defense cannot cover. The offense completes pass after pass for explosive gains.

The defense cannot win. If they stay light, they get run over. If they go heavy, they get spread out and exploited in coverage. The offense dictates terms. The defense is always reacting, always wrong, always behind.

This is the substitution game. Traditional offenses lose the substitution game because they substitute based on down and distance, telegraphing their intentions. First and ten, they bring in 11 personnel. Second and short, they bring in 21 personnel. Third and long, they bring in 10 personnel. The defense adjusts accordingly and the offense loses the element of surprise. The Five Terrors offense never substitutes. The same eleven players are on the field for every snap. The defense cannot adjust without risking a penalty or being caught with the wrong personnel. The offense always has the advantage.

The incompatibility crisis is magnified by pre-snap motion. The offense uses motion on nearly every play to force the defense to adjust and reveal their coverage. The H-back motions across the formation. The defense has to decide: do they follow him with a defender, meaning man coverage, or let him go, meaning zone coverage? The quarterback sees the adjustment and checks into the correct play. If the defense is in man coverage, the offense runs play-action because the defenders will be focused on their assignments and not reading the play. If the defense is in zone coverage, the offense runs power because zone defenses are typically softer and easier to run against.

The motion also reveals the Mike linebacker. In traditional offenses, the center identifies the Mike linebacker by pointing at him pre-snap. The offensive line adjusts their protection based on where the Mike is. In the Five Terrors offense, the motion forces the defense to declare who the Mike is. If the H-back motions across the formation and a linebacker shifts with him, that linebacker is the Mike. The quarterback sees this and checks into the correct protection or play. The defense cannot hide. The offense has all the information.

Specific Offensive Scenarios: How The Five Terrors Offense Attacks

Against a nickel defense, the offense runs power. The defense has five or six players in the box. The offense has seven blockers at the point of attack. The offensive line down blocks, the backside guard pulls, the in-line tight ends seal the edge, and the H-back runs through the hole. The defense is out-numbered. The offense gains five yards. On the next play, the offense runs the same play again. Five more yards. The defense cannot stop it. After two or three plays, the defense is forced to substitute into base personnel. The offense has won the substitution game.

Against a base defense, the offense spreads. The defense has seven or eight players in the box. The offense checks into a spread formation, flexing four tight ends wide. The defense is now forced to cover four athletic tight ends with linebackers and safeties. The offense runs play-action. The linebackers bite on the run fake. The tight ends run seam routes. The quarterback delivers the ball to the open tight end for a gain of twenty yards. The defense is caught out of position. The offense has exploited the coverage mismatch.

Against a goal-line defense, the offense uses deception. The defense stacks the box with a 6-2 or 5-3 front, expecting a power run. The offense shows a heavy formation with all five tight ends on the line of scrimmage. The defense is set. At the snap, the offensive line run blocks, the H-back takes a step toward the line, and the defense commits. One of the in-line tight ends releases from his block and leaks into the flat on a shallow crossing route. The quarterback delivers the ball to the leaking tight end for an easy touchdown. The defense was so focused on stopping the run that they could not react to the pass.

Against a blitz, the offense has multiple options. If the defense shows blitz with five or six rushers, the offense can protect with seven or eight blockers, keeping the H-back and in-line tight ends in to block. The math works. The quarterback has time. The Move/Flex tight ends run routes. The quarterback delivers the ball. The blitz fails. Or the offense can go empty, spreading all five tight ends wide. If the defense sends six rushers, they only have five in coverage. The quarterback identifies the hot route, gets the ball out in under two seconds, and the tight end catches the ball in space against single coverage. Either way, the offense wins.

Against a two-high safety defense, the offense attacks the middle of the field. Two-high safety defenses are designed to eliminate explosive plays by keeping two safeties deep. The weakness of two-high is the middle of the field, specifically the area between the linebackers and the safeties. The offense runs play-action. The linebackers step up. The tight ends run crossing routes through the middle of the field. The safeties are too deep to react. The tight ends are wide open. The quarterback delivers the ball for a gain of fifteen yards. The two-high defense cannot stop the intermediate passing game.

Against a single-high safety defense, the offense attacks vertically. Single-high safety defenses are vulnerable to vertical routes because the free safety has to cover the entire deep middle of the field. The offense spreads four tight ends wide. The Move/Flex tight ends run vertical seam routes. The free safety has to choose which seam to cover. The quarterback reads the safety's leverage and throws to the open tight end. The defense cannot cover everyone. The offense completes the pass for an explosive gain.

Running RPO, the offense reads the overhang defender. The offensive line run blocks. The H-back runs through the hole. The quarterback reads the leverage of the strong safety or outside linebacker. If the defender steps down to stop the run, the quarterback throws a quick pass to a tight end running a slant or flat route. If the defender drops into coverage, the quarterback hands the ball off. The defense is wrong. The offense is right.

Why This Offense Has Not Been Done In The NFL Before

The Five Terrors offense has not been done before for three reasons. First, traditional offensive coaches are conservative and risk-averse. They do not want to be the first coach to try something radical and fail. They would rather run a traditional offense with running backs and wide receivers and lose in a conventional way than run an unconventional offense and be criticized for being too creative. Second, finding the right personnel is extraordinarily difficult. The offense requires five to seven tight ends who are athletic, versatile, and competent in multiple roles. Most teams draft and develop specialists, players who are elite at one skill but limited in others. The Five Terrors offense requires players who can do everything, and those players are rare. Third, the offense requires exceptional coaching, communication, and mental toughness. Like the McDaniels-Brady Patriots offense, this system demands that every player understands their assignments in multiple formations, adjusts on the fly without hesitation, and executes with precision. One mental mistake, one blown assignment, one missed adjustment, and the entire scheme collapses. The margin for error is razor-thin.

But the pieces are in place. NFL teams already carry three or four tight ends on their rosters. Teams already value versatile, athletic tight ends who can block and catch. The players exist. What is missing is a coach with the vision and the courage to commit to the system, build the roster around tight ends instead of wide receivers, and run the Five Terrors offense as a base.

Weaknesses and Limitations

The Five Terrors offense is not perfect. It has weaknesses that can be exploited by well-coached defenses with the right personnel.

The most significant weakness is the lack of elite vertical speed. The offense does not have wide receivers who can run 4.4 forties and stretch the field vertically. The Move/Flex tight ends are fast for their size, running sub-4.8 forties, but they are not burners. If a defense commits to playing two-deep safeties and takes away the intermediate passing game, the offense may struggle to score quickly. The offense is built for sustained drives, not explosive plays. If the offense falls behind early and needs to score quickly, the lack of elite vertical speed could be a problem.

The second weakness is vulnerability to elite speed rushers. The offense protects the quarterback with seven or eight blockers on most plays, but if the defense has an elite speed rusher who can beat the in-line tight end one-on-one, the protection could break down. The in-line tight ends are good blockers, but they are not as good as offensive tackles. An elite pass rusher like Myles Garrett or Nick Bosa could exploit this weakness and disrupt the passing game.

The third weakness is personnel scarcity and injury vulnerability. The offense requires five to seven tight ends who are athletic, versatile, and competent in multiple roles. If one or two of these players get injured, particularly the H-back who is the primary running back, the offense loses significant depth and the scheme could break down. The team must prioritize building depth at the tight end position, rostering multiple players who can fill each role. The financial and draft capital required to build this depth is significant, and teams must be strategic in their acquisitions.

The fourth weakness is predictability if the offense becomes one-dimensional. If the offense relies too heavily on power runs and does not use enough deception, motion, and play-action, the defense will load the box and stop the run. The offense must maintain schematic fluidity, using variable tempos, constant motion, empty formations, and diverse play-calling to keep the defense off-balance. If the offense becomes predictable, the scheme fails.

The fifth weakness is vulnerability to hybrid linebackers and safeties. A defensive coordinator could counter the Five Terrors offense by rostering hybrid linebackers or safeties who weigh 220 to 230 pounds and have the size to play the run and the speed to cover tight ends. If the defense can field multiple hybrid defenders who can match up with the Move/Flex tight ends, the offense loses its coverage advantage. To counter this, the offense must use motion to identify which hybrid defender is assigned to which tight end, then attack that matchup with isolation routes and physical contests.

How To Counter The Weaknesses

The offense counters its weaknesses through adjustments and game planning.

Against two-deep safeties, the offense attacks the middle of the field. Two-deep safeties take away the vertical passing game, but they create space in the middle of the field. The offense runs crossing routes, seam routes, and intermediate posts, attacking the space between the linebackers and the safeties. The tight ends are big enough to win contested catches and physical enough to gain yards after the catch. The offense sustains drives and scores points even without explosive vertical plays.

Against elite speed rushers, the offense chips and slides protection. The H-back or a Move/Flex tight end chips the speed rusher before releasing into a route, slowing him down and giving the offensive tackle help. The offensive line slides protection toward the speed rusher, giving him extra attention. The quarterback gets the ball out quickly on RPOs, play-action passes, and empty quick passes, not giving the speed rusher time to get home.

Against injuries, the offense rotates players and cross-trains. Every tight end is coached to play multiple roles. The in-line tight ends can play the H-back position if needed. The Move/Flex tight ends can play in-line. The offense has depth and flexibility to adjust when injuries occur.

Against predictability, the offense maintains schematic diversity. The offensive coordinator scripts plays to show multiple formations, use constant motion, and attack different areas of the field. The offense runs power, runs zone, throws play-action, throws from spread, throws from empty, and runs RPOs, all in the same drive. The defense cannot predict what is coming.

Against hybrid defenders, the offense uses motion to identify matchups and attacks them with isolation routes. If the defense has a hybrid linebacker covering a Move/Flex tight end, the offense motions the tight end across the formation to force the linebacker to declare his assignment. Then the offense runs an isolation route, putting the tight end one-on-one against the linebacker on a post route. The tight end is bigger, and the offense wins the physical contest.

Coaching Requirements

The Five Terrors offense requires a specific type of coaching staff. The offensive coordinator must be intelligent, creative, and willing to take risks. The offensive line coach must be able to teach power blocking and zone schemes. The tight ends coach must be able to develop versatile players who can block, catch, and run routes. The entire staff must be willing to invest extensive time in teaching, film study, and communication.

The offensive coordinator must script plays to establish the offense's identity. The goal is to run power effectively early in the game, forcing the defense to commit to stopping the run. Then the coordinator uses play-action, spread formations, and empty formations to exploit the defense's aggression. The coordinator must also be able to adjust on the fly based on what the defense is doing. If the defense stays in nickel, the coordinator runs power. If the defense goes to base, the coordinator spreads or goes empty.

The position coaches must develop players who can do multiple things. The tight ends coach must teach the in-line tight ends to block like offensive tackles and catch passes in traffic. The coach must teach the Move/Flex tight ends to run routes like wide receivers and block defensive backs. The coach must teach the H-back to run with power like John Riggins, lead block like a fullback, and catch passes out of the backfield. Every player must be cross-trained in multiple roles.

The entire coaching staff must emphasize communication. The offense requires constant communication between the quarterback, the offensive line, and the tight ends. The quarterback must identify the Mike linebacker and check into the correct play. The offensive line must communicate blocking assignments and identify stunts. The tight ends must communicate route adjustments based on coverage. If the communication breaks down, the offense breaks down. Like the McDaniels-Brady Patriots offense, this system requires every player to be mentally tough, cognitively excellent, and capable of executing under pressure without hesitation.

Conclusion: The Five Terrors, An Offense In Waiting

The Five Terrors offense is not a gimmick. It is not a goal-line package. It is a complete offensive system built to dominate the modern NFL. It eliminates the need for traditional running backs and wide receivers. It presents a heavy personnel grouping that forces defenses into an incompatibility crisis. It runs power football with overwhelming force, then spreads and throws to mismatches, then goes empty and attacks with quick passes. It controls the clock, sustains drives, and scores points. It is the offense the NFL needs but does not yet have the courage to build.

The players exist. NFL teams already carry multiple tight ends. Teams already value versatile, athletic tight ends who can block and catch. The scheme is sound. It is built on proven principles of power football, play-action, positional ambiguity, and quick passing from empty. What is missing is a coach with the vision to see it and the courage to implement it.

This offense will win championships. It will confuse defenses, frustrate coordinators, and make defenses one-dimensional. It will force teams to choose between stopping the run or defending the pass. It will create mismatches, sustain drives, and control games. It will dominate.

The Five Terrors offense is not a dream. It is an offense in waiting. And if a few players fit the needs with elite speed, that makes the Five Terrors offense that much scarier.

See my 5-6 version of the 3-2-6 three down dime