Anyone who's paid attention to the Patriots over the last decade knows that the quarterback is mainly all anyone cares about. Ten years ago it was all "who's gonna be Brady's hier?" Last year, it was "who's gonna be replace Brady?" This year, it's "who's gonna start at quarterback?" And with that, I'm gonna see what I can find out about the Patriots' quarterbacks.
Now before I continue, this isn't to say people don't care about the rest of the team, it's just as fans, we care about the quarterback position above everything else. Not a surprise, as modern fans care more about the offense than the defense.
It was rainy and drops appeared to be a problem for the pass catchers. Here's how Henry McKenna scored the day, "- In competitive team drills: Newton 12/20, Jones 13/20, Stidham 8/15, Hoyer 2/6, INT."
During the rain, Cam Newton was apparently erratic with his throws. Looking more like the Cam fans came to know in 2020, especially from a mechanics standpoint. At this point he's not being asked to run but the problem has never been with his legs, it's with his arm. That's the thing that people for get about with quarterbacks and it's what makes him different from a running back. However, he needs to show he can throw with accuracy better than the running backs on the roster.
Here's some thoughts on Cam:
Phil Perry of NBC writing, Cam "struggled with his accuracy at times throughout the session." "It's fair to wonder if Newton's mechanics and level of accuracy simply are what they are. Though Mac Jones did not have an immaculate day of practice -- understanding the Patriots are one day into a three-day mandatory minicamp -- it's also fair to wonder how long the quarterback job in New England will be Newton's if there are more days like Monday."
Ryan Hannable of WEEI wrote about Newton, "Had a number of overthrows, which included in both 7-on-7 and 11-on-11 work, as well as goal-line throws."
Karl Thompson of the Boston Globe wrote, "He threw the ball with good velocity despite the rain, though he at times struggled to find his touch and sailed a few balls near the red zone. He also couldn’t connect with the speedy Nelson Agholor on his three attempts at deep throws, overthrowing two of them while Agholor dropped the third in tight coverage."
Greg Bedard wrote about Newton, "Newton's hand was not an issue. But he was still inaccurate on some throws as usual. Even on-air reps in the end zone, his ball was very flat and without much touch." "Newton threw one pass to Kristian Wilkerson what was awful ... typical of last season, he geared up, dipped his shoulders too much, and threw it into the turf."
Evan Lazar of CLNS wrote, "Evaluating Newton’s lower-body mechanics and footwork would be premature. His timing is improving in the offense, but his throwing motion is still the old Cam."
Mac Jones had a good day, opening up his offense finally but is still looking like a rookie. Mike Reiss said he looked "dialed in," and Mike Giardi said he had a, "solid day, good command." There were a lot of positives about said about Jones, from his pre snap reads to his deep ball. The two main take aways from the day was he's showing improvement and he's looking like the best quarterback on the field. If he can continue to be the best quarterback on the field, Newton won't be the front runner come week one.
Here's what was said about Big Mac:
Alex Barth of 98.5 the hub and CLNS media wrote about Jones saying, "Jones’ improved confidence is clear as well, and he’s starting to throw the ball more downfield in team drills. One such throw stood out on Monday, when he hit Devin Asiasi (who has had a nice few weeks himself) on a contested back-shoulder route about 15-20 yards up the seam."
Hannable wrote about Jones, "he is showing signs of progress when it comes to being comfortable with the offense and taking more chances with throws down the field."
Thompson wrote about Jones, "Jones’s accuracy remained solid in the rainy conditions even as other quarterbacks appeared to struggle and sail throws, though he also missed one or two in drills and had one batted at the line of scrimmage in 11-on-11s."
Bedard wrote about Jones, "Thought Jones was the best of all the quarterbacks easily. He pushed the ball down the field more and his pocket movement really stood out. He stepped up numerous times against pressure and delivered strikes down the field. That shows progress. He struggled against pressure a few weeks ago."
Evan Lazar wrote, "Those are the types of downfield throws that Jones wasn’t necessarily making during OTAs, but as he becomes more decisive, the rookie is showing signs of improvement."
Stidham also opened up his game and is doing enough to have his name thrown in with the previous two quarterbacks, with Doug Kyed writing about Stidham "(he's) most consistently solid option so far." The thing with Stidham is his decision making. He looks good in practice but he apparently takes too long to make his decisions. However when he's rushed, his decisions making goes out the window. The NFL game maybe too fast for him.
Here's some quotes on Stiddy:
Barth wrote about Stidham, "He opened things up a bit more today than the last time we saw him, including a deep pass to Nelson Agholor that he landed right in the bread basket - only for Agholor to drop it (there were a number of drops on Monday due to the rain)."
Mike Giardi tweeted, "Best throw of the day came from Jarrett Stidham during a 7-on-7 period late in practice. A deep shot down the sideline to Nelson Agholor. Unfortunately, the speedy wideout dropped it and then punted the ball into an opposite field."
Hannable also wrote that the best throw came from Stidham but says it was from a different drill writing, "The speedy receiver ran a go-route up the left side in 11-on-11 work and Stidham threw a very nice ball roughy 40 yards downfield, but it fell off his fingertips"
Brian Mazique of the Heavy wrote about Stidham, "Unfortunately, he is stuck in an indeterminate state somewhere between rookie Mac Jones and veteran Brian Hoyer, but definitely behind Cam Newton"?
And Ian Logue summed Stidham up, "Stidham remains as a piece that Belichick will need to add value to because his long-term future with the team has clearly changed drastically compared to last offseason. Building him up and recovering a draft choice certainly makes the most sense and barring major changes, that will probably be what eventually happens"
Hoyer appears to be feeling the pressure abandoning his safe intelligent conservative style for a more gun slinger approach. Hoyer had suitors this offseason but choose to stay around to resign with the Patriots. Hoyer has the most knowledge of any of the quarterbacks but lacks the physical gifts of the other three players on the roster to be able to take advantage of what's in his head.
Here's a quote about Hoyer. Note, not much was said about the veteran on the day, and all most every quote was different way to say this:
Phil Perry wrote, "On one of the few reps Brian Hoyer had in team (offense v. defense) periods today resulted in an interception by Kyle Van Noy."
Hoyer was asked about coaching Mac Jones and said, ""I mean I'm not the quarterback coach so that's not really my responsibility."
Hoyer would later say when it comes to answering the others questions, "that's my responsibility, being the most experienced quarterback in that room is to kind of share that wealth of knowledge and then go from there."
From Hoyer's comments, to the dismay of many Patriots fans, the guy still wants to put the pads on and play. And the talk of him being a coach may actually push him away from the position.
Doug Kyed of NESN wrote, "So far, if there is a battle, it’s been tight between the four quarterbacks through four open OTAs and minicamp sessions. Newton is 16-of-27 (59.3 percent) in somewhat limited team reps. He missed one practice and stopped throwing early in another session
because of a hand injury. Jones is 29-of-42 (69 percent) while alternating between No. 2 and No. 3 QB duties and relying on check downs. Stidham is 34-of-46 (73.9 percent) and has probably been the Patriots’ most consistently solid option so far this spring. Veteran Brian Hoyer is 22-of-34 (64.7 percent) with an interception."
The quarterbacks will be in the spotlight the rest of the off and preseason. Other camp battles will take a back seat, so guys like Wes Farnsworth will battle Joe Cardona without pressure from the media.
As for the rest, Meyers is still looking like the Patriots number one and Van Noy hasn't missed a beat, while Harry, Gunner and Nordic, are apparently continuing to give coaches something to think about.